Eli Manning .... the Greatest Manning QB

[PlastikBulletz]

That would upset too many fans, the boys already have a qb in place ready to take them to the super bowl.

No. No way sir.

[morris_mat]

I was just tellin the old lady that Eli made some great passes in this game and that he was better that Peyton. They need to stop with the Peyton train and stop talking about him Eli is the man......even if he has an oversized head.

Ps I was routing for Brady cause I have a man crush on him

[scubasteven25]

Eli is the better QB of the Manning family, but I still despise him and his father for their draft day antics and whining. Plus Peyton has a much more likeable personality.

[VorTexan]

Both are good. I havn't cared for Eli since the draft snub.

Peyton has definitely done more with less. Eli has had some LUCKY moments people!


"the helmet catch" in the first win and New England drops in the second (yes there was more to it but..)

He has been blessed with a better team than Peyton.

[PlastikBulletz]

I was just tellin the old lady that Eli made some great passes in this game and that he was better that Peyton. They need to stop with the Peyton train and stop talking about him Eli is the man......even if he has an oversized head.

Ps I was routing for Brady cause I have a man crush on him

Most every man does with his "jawline"

[FISHUNTER]

Ps I was routing for Brady cause I have a man crush on him

Was that part of the discussion with your old lady also?

[Brock Middlebrook]

I would pick a healthy Payton

[PlastikBulletz]

Was that part of the discussion with your old lady also?

Don't lie. You know he has "just the right amount of scruff"

[PlastikBulletz]

I would pick a healthy Payton

For Dallas or overall?

[Chad C]

and Cooper was the best athlete in the family. At 6'4" , 4.4 speed ,nobody could stop him at WR . Sadly his college career was cut short due to narrowing of the spinal canal (spinal stenosis)

To bad he was talking about Eli... I remember the interview, well.

[quackerback]

x2!

As long as his doctor's aren't BS his medical issues. His own private practicioner says he has a few more years in the tank. Peyton is a much better Qb, and team leader. Eli is a whinny little b!!!!.

i don't know how you can say that Eli is not a leader. how many times just this year has he taken his team down the field for the lead at the end of a game.

[Cajun Blake]

I would pick a healthy Payton

and so would Tracy Porter .... ... for the pick 6

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nr7DeUZumcs"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nr7DeUZumcs[/ame]

[Bluesman]

Eli won me a grand tonight. He's cool.

[quackerback]

His bro has done more with less. Both are great. Please lord, let the elder of the 2 become a Cowboy.

this is comical. i did not know Peyton played corner and Qb. i guess i should have watched more Colts games in the past. Romo had one of the best seasons of his career this year. you are really fooling yourself if you think Peyton would have made a difference. the offense was not the problem this year.

[whodat]

payton is better, but brady might disagree