Eli Manning .... the Greatest Manning QB

[Cajun Blake]

this topic can be argued til the cows come home but IMO, Eli stands head and shoulders above Peyton when it comes to post season and performing under pressure . This dude is clutch and makes things happen in the 4thQ - his numbers don't lie

Eli career post season record : 8-3 with 5 consecutive road wins , 2 Lombardi's , 2 SB MVP's

Peyton post season record : 9-10 , 1 Lombardi , 1 SB MVP


#18 will be hard pressed to get back to the SB as his career is all but over .

#10 just finished his 8th NFL season , and at 31 yrs old, he has plenty of gas left in the tank . Won't be surprised to see him back in the title game in the future.


when the game's on the line, I'll take Eli over Peyton all day long

[PlastikBulletz]

His bro has done more with less. Both are great. Please lord, let the elder of the 2 become a Cowboy.

[zztex]

this topic can be argued til the cows come home but IMO, Eli stands head and shoulders above Peyton when it comes to post season and performing under pressure . This dude is clutch and makes things happen in the 4thQ - his numbers don't lie

Eli career post season record : 8-3 with 5 consecutive road wins , 2 Lombardi's , 2 SB MVP's

Peyton post season record : 9-10 , 1 Lombardi , 1 SB MVP


#18 will be hard pressed to get back to the SB as his career is all but over .

#10 just finished his 8th NFL season , and at 31 yrs old, he has plenty of gas left in the tank . Won't be surprised to see him back in the title game in the future.


when the game's on the line, I'll take Eli over Peyton all day long

X2

[DorothyNotKeegan]

His bro has done more with less. Both are great. Please lord, let the elder of the 2 become a Cowboy.

Ha! It'd take more than Peyton to make them win...

[Jaspro]

His bro has done more with less. Both are great. Please lord, let the elder of the 2 become a Cowboy.

x2!

As long as his doctor's aren't BS his medical issues. His own private practicioner says he has a few more years in the tank. Peyton is a much better Qb, and team leader. Eli is a whinny little b!!!!.

[BearStrike2010]

I was lucky enough to watch him play most of his college career at ole miss since I grew up in Oxford. He certainly lead the rebels.

[Chad C]

When Payton was drafted he said...

"If you think I'm good, wait until you see my brother."

[Smell the Glove]

X2

X3

[panhandlehunter]

No way Eli is better, even though he has won one more super bowl. Peytons teams have never been great but he managed to at least get them to the playoffs every year. You saw how the Colts did without him. Peyton is clutch as well, he just hasn't had the teams that Eli has had.

[Cajun Blake]

When Payton was drafted he said...

"If you think I'm good, wait until you see my brother."

and Cooper was the best athlete in the family. At 6'4" , 4.4 speed ,nobody could stop him at WR . Sadly his college career was cut short due to narrowing of the spinal canal (spinal stenosis)

[Tmag]

He sure made it happen tonight.

[Gunner97]

I think Eli has taken his game to another level. I have always thought Peyton was a great QB, but it's all about the rings and Eli now has 2.

[DS_1974]

His bro has done more with less. Both are great. Please lord, let the elder of the 2 become a Cowboy.

Please Lord make it stop.

Though this would be a Jerry Jones-esque move. Just another in the line of his many idiotic moves.

[PlastikBulletz]

Please Lord make it stop.

Though this would be a Jerry Jones-esque move. Just another in the line of his many idiotic moves.

A little less Jerry and we would have no problem. We would do well to have Peyton as the General. Romo is nothing more than Jerrys pony boy.

[Stuck]

His bro has done more with less. Both are great. Please lord, let the elder of the 2 become a Cowboy.

That would upset too many fans, the boys already have a qb in place ready to take them to the super bowl.