n arkansas each year we would always make up our own soap bait. Melt ivory soap down and add another ingrediate- I forget name, but can get it from pharmacy. We caught a ton of fish and had clean hands
I've used it. To me Ivory works just as well. IMO, soap works best in moving water. The river, the creek is where I have the best results. Not so much on the lake.
I've caught blue cats up to 8 lbs. on it nothing any larger.
Comment