Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
American Sniper
Collapse
X
-
Read the book 3 or 4 times, stood on 35 for the procession. I am a huge fan if Chris and what he stood for. I will see the movie this weekend and hope all I've heard is true and that it stays with his story better than Lone Survivor movie did. That one did not do Marcus's or the villagers who helped hims story as told in his book justice very well in my opinion.
Comment
-
Originally posted by helibow View PostSaw it in a packed theater here in Colorado Springs, where we have 2 military bases and the Air Force Academy.... it was a very interesting experience! Listening to the comments and reactions of those around me was eye opening, many whispers about how real it was, "this takes me back" etc. The most interesting was when the movie was over - again a packed house, probably 400+ in the room... there was not a SINGLE sound while all of us exited that theater. All you could hear was the rustling of clothes. The mood in the air was palpable. Saw lots of wives and girlfriends tightly latched on to their man.
Great movie balanced with some good light hearted moments.
watched merican sniper last night at the house, really thought eastwood hit a homer with this movie. so sad how his life ended. so sad.
better than lone survivor. by far.
Comment
-
I will go see the movie at some point. In the book it was a woman with a RPG that was his first kill. I know movies can't go word for word with a book. It would be 10 hrs long. I never saw "Lone Survivor". I read the book multiple times and was lucky to actually meet Morgan, Marcus' brother, in Germany.
I have the utmost respect for both of these warriors.
BMC (ret) Cook
Comment
-
There's a big difference between shooting a woman and a kid! That's the one part they should get right. Also how did mustafa make 1000m shots with that scope and rifle? The whole last scene on the roof in the sandstorm wasn't in the book as I recall. As far as I remember he didn't shoot the other sniper at 2100m either. And also my 8 yr old doesn't flinch when he shoots his deer rifle as much as cooper does when he shoots in the movie. My brother who is a marine scout sniper was really ****** about him leaving his rifle at the end. I'm told that would never happen! Ever! Snipers don't do that!
Comment
-
Originally posted by 55jake View PostThere's a big difference between shooting a woman and a kid! That's the one part they should get right. Also how did mustafa make 1000m shots with that scope and rifle? The whole last scene on the roof in the sandstorm wasn't in the book as I recall. As far as I remember he didn't shoot the other sniper at 2100m either. And also my 8 yr old doesn't flinch when he shoots his deer rifle as much as cooper does when he shoots in the movie. My brother who is a marine scout sniper was really ****** about him leaving his rifle at the end. I'm told that would never happen! Ever! Snipers don't do that!
Seriously? I bet you were ****** about the fake baby too!
Comment
-
Amazing movie! Makes me think about things so differently. I went to meps 4 different times trying to be field artillery and go over seas. Long story short it didn't happen. This movie just made me want to drink a beer and thank God for people like Chris Kyle. He is definitely a hero and a mentor.
Comment
-
Wife and I went last night. Eastwood created a great story line based on Kyle's past. That said, the movie itself was ok to us. Cooper flinching, Mustafa made an off rest shot, the rifle Mustafa used, some of the assault formations were unpolished, sandstorm sensationalism, etc were constant reminders of the Hollywood effect.
End of the day, a nice tribute to an American Hero.
Comment
-
Originally posted by 55jake View PostThere's a big difference between shooting a woman and a kid! That's the one part they should get right. Also how did mustafa make 1000m shots with that scope and rifle? The whole last scene on the roof in the sandstorm wasn't in the book as I recall. As far as I remember he didn't shoot the other sniper at 2100m either. And also my 8 yr old doesn't flinch when he shoots his deer rifle as much as cooper does when he shoots in the movie. My brother who is a marine scout sniper was really ****** about him leaving his rifle at the end. I'm told that would never happen! Ever! Snipers don't do that!
Having said that, you should read Victory Point http://www.amazon.com/Victory-Point-...=victory+point to get another look & perspective from what Lone Survivor displays. It's pretty in depth & will kind of dumb down the original, but you have to take all sides & aspects. Some will actually be a bit irked at this book but it is what it is.
Comment
Comment