Settle this family argument

[baldybarton]

I like #2 better!

[Terry]

Dad wins

[pblaetz]

#2. But both are probably the same age class!

[Cajun Blake]

my guestimates .... Dad's deer @ 90" ; your deer around 110"

[d_e_smith]

The shadow on the wall appears to be bigger for deer #2 by about 20".

[Bisch]

Yours will score higher than your dad's!

Bisch

[CrossTimbers]

Get them scored, take the subjectivity out of it.

[whitetailtrail]

Preciate the thoughts! This thread sure filled up quick!

[whitetailtrail]

Get them scored, take the subjectivity out of it.

Then it takes all the fun away!!

[Tubby]

2nd buck is bigger.... Spread measurement is measuring nothing but air...

[.270_Maniac]

2nd one hands down!! Nice bucks

[Poppy]

#2 with the tine length

[BO-N-ARO]

Clear as a bell to me, his is wider ......... and yours is taller!

[kingofhill76248]

Fist one is wider but the second one is taller. Both are nice.
I like the taller tines.

[Speedgoat]

#2 is bigger.