Settle this family argument

[whitetailtrail]

Alright, my dad and I have been disagreeing for years on " whose buck is bigger " his argument is that his has more width, and mine has more height, thickness wise my buck is probably slightly larger.

But here's the thing, we don't want to officially measure them because that actually ends the little feud. We just want opinions! So here they are.

No monsters but the first deer we have had shoulder mounted. My dads will be the first deer pictures, and mine will be the second.

Lets hear it!

[muley4x4]

2 hands down.

[Shane]

The taller one is bigger. Both could have benefitted from a couple more years though.

[LakeJake]

I like number two

[whitetailtrail]

That's what I like to see!!

Keep em coming

[unclefish]

Taller wins in a landslide.

[Death from Above]

Buck 2 is bigger. Go ahead and have the measured. U will win

[JHT]

Take the old man to the eye doctor this week.

[geauxgruene]

Kinda like momma....dad's always right.

[whitetailtrail]

The taller one is bigger. Both could have benefitted from a couple more years though.

Sure wish we could have let them, but on our place, we would never see em again.

[Texas8point]

both real nice deer, congrats. i gotta go with # 2

[Smart]

2 no question...

[Shane]

Sure wish we could have let them, but on our place, we would never see em again.

I was just messin' with ya. They're both beautiful bucks, and I would be proud to have 'em hanging on my wall too.

[Eric Pence]

2 will score higher

[TXHUNT3R]

Take the old man to the eye doctor this week.

lol THIS!!!

2 for sure!