Which one would you shoot?

[Roscoe]

I'd shoot the 200, pull the ear tag out and put a nice studded earring in there for the LDP! :-)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Mac...]

Depends on what county I'm in and how many bucks I can take.
If I could take 2, I'd offer the 200" a candy bar and when he came in to get it, I'd beat him to death with a flyswatter. Then arrow the other one before either of them knew what him em. LMAO

[Speedgoat]

I am not a fan of high dollar genetic engineering, so I would shoot neither. I will wait for the spike or fat doe.

[JeffJ]

Too many variables. Is he like our tagged buck and wild as a banchee? He was dropped off at 14-15 months old. We will seldom see him in the flesh. Saw him for about 10 minutes this morning. He is only 4.5 so we have three years until he would even be touchable. Now if the deer had spent 4-6 years in a small pen and was relatively tame only to be let out in September to be shot...I would probably pass.

We are looking at some 2010 fawns from a breeder getting out of the biz. If we turn some out we will treat them like any other deer and cull at 3.5yo if needed.

I DO love some pen raised quail hunting though.

[outdoordaddy]

I'd start slinging carbon and try to get both!

[scissorhands]

I would aim my bow at the sky and shoot. Which ever one it hit would be dinner!

[lanceodom]

I would shoot the 150/160 and since the tagged 200" deer would probably be pretty tame already, I would teach him to drive a car. Then I would grow a moustache and the two of us would travel around the country getting into all kinds of adventures together.

thats funny

[drepka]

200

[az2tx]

I have 3 tag bucks on my place all have been running wild for 4 yrs, tags only mean they were darted once, not tame