Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Yeah! The sun was finally out, so I got the chronograph out

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Yeah! The sun was finally out, so I got the chronograph out

    Been shooting 10mms for at least 30 years, never fired one over a chronograph, until today.

    I learned a couple things today. One turns out that most of the ammo, I have been saving and carrying in my 10mm for years, turns out to be some very light loads. I have not had the boxes for either type of ammo, I have had my 10mm mags loaded with, so I am not sure what exactly the two types of ammo are. I know the nickel plated cases are some type of Federal ammo. The other ammo I have, have gold colored hollow cavity bullets, that I would guess are Speer bullets, but really don't know.

    The Federal hollow cavity ammo, turns out to be loaded very light. I only got around 1000 fps, when fired from my pistol. Then when I shot those same loads from the carbine, I got close to 1100 fps.

    The Sig Sauer FMJ ammo I have, I got 1240 fps, to 1280 fps, from the pistol. From the carbine, I was getting upper 1300 fps, the lowest number I got was 1386 fps, the highest was 1436 fps.

    I also shot up the rest of the old hollow cavity ammo, with the gold colored bullets. I have no idea what they are, I bought up $600 of assorted 10mm ammo from a gun shop years ago. I saved two different types of hollow cavity ammo that looked like good self defense ammo. Whatever the rounds were with the gold colored bullets, those produced around 1200 fps, from the handgun, then mid 1300 fps from the carbine. The nickel plated ammo, I know that stuff was Federal, because those cases, have FC on the cases. The unknown brass, has markings that look like Starline brass. I know all of that ammo, I bought back in 2003. I did not know Starline was in business at that point, never heard of them making loaded ammo. Possibly some small ammo company used Starline brass, and probably some Speer bullets.

    All three types of ammo, were 180 gr.

    I was expecting higher velocities from all three different types of ammo. Kind of surprised the cheap, FMJs produced the highest velocity. I am guessing the Federal ammo were reduced loads, to reduce recoil, for faster follow up shots.

    So after burning up the last of my old hollow cavity ammo, I have been carrying around in my pistol for years, I decided it was time to start loading some more ammo.

    My Hornady manual shows a max charge of 9.5 gr. for Longshot. I started off with 8 gr. of Longshot, thinking I was going to be up around 11 gr. to 12 gr. for a max load with the carbine. Right off the 8 gr. of Longshot was definitely hotter than any of the factory loads I have shot so far. I did not run any of the handloads across the chronograph, because it was later in the day, I did not have enough light, so I did not even set the chronograph up for the handloads.

    To my surprise, 9.5 gr. was very close to max charge. I decided 10 gr. would be max. I went all the way up to 11 gr. but did not like the looks of the primers. 10.5 gr. was a bit hotter than I like. So I backed up to 10 gr. I am going to load up some at 10 gr. with large pistol primer brass. Then I am going to load some rounds with the small primer brass and see what those look like. with the same powder charges.

    It looks like the only small primer 10mm brass I have, are what's left of those two boxes of CCI Blazer brass.

    At 9.5 gr. to 10 gr. of powder, the recoil is a lot heavier than with any of the four types of factory 180 gr. ammo that I have shot through the carbine so far. Tomorrow, if the sun is out, I will run some over the chronograph. Cool thing, is the handloads hit the same spot as the factory loads. Hopefully the Longshot works good with the longer carbine barrel. I noticed that the factory Federal ammo I ran through both guns, gave almost the same velocity out of both guns. So I am guessing whatever powder Federal used, was a very fast burning powder, that was mostly burnt by the end of the handguns 5" barrel. The Longshot is supposed to be the slowest burning powder, of all of the powders that produced good velocities with a 10mm, shooting 180 gr. jacketed bullets. So hopefully the carbine barrel will give me quite a bit higher numbers from the carbine.

    I set the gun up on a couple of bags, that gave me a better rest that the first time I shot the gun. I was able to get better groups from the gun. At this point, I have the gun working perfectly with all three mags. The bolt is held open after the last shot with all three mags, and only after the last round, not the second to the last round. The gun feeds beautifully, and the brass does not have all of the marks, that I was getting previously.
    Last edited by RifleBowPistol; 12-10-2022, 11:16 PM.

    #2
    Here are some pictures of the brass, the first picture is of brass, that was factory CCI Blazer ammo, shot through the gun, after the first round of polishing the chamber. I did not find any of the brass, that was fired through the gun, before I did any polishing to the chamber.

    The second picture is of some brass from some of the ammo I loaded today, and shot through the gun, after polishing the chamber twice.

    I threw away many of the pieces of brass that were fired through the gun, before I did any polishing the chamber. Those pieces of brass, were all questionable, to reload. The marks or rings in the brass were pretty deep. I know I kept some, but did not find any easily when searching through my 10mm brass.

    The dents in the mouth of the brass, I shot today, were done by my brass catcher. Without the brass catcher, the brass does not get damaged. But all of the brass fired with the brass catcher on, have dented mouths. Not sure what the brass is hitting, that would dent the brass.
    Last edited by RifleBowPistol; 12-10-2022, 11:16 PM.

    Comment


      #3
      The ammo I am going to load up first for the carbine, and the pistol, are some 180 gr. Sierra hollow cavity or hollow point, the old label says Power Jacket. The front of the bullets have some pretty good sized cavities in the nose. Since I need ammo for my pistol now, and it does not seem that I can load ammo any hotter for the carbine. I guess I will load ammo that will work in both guns. Which is good I guess, then I don't have to be careful about what ammo works in which gun. I had planned to load ammo for the carbine with one type of bullet, and then use some other bullet for the pistol ammo, so I know which are carbine and which are pistol rounds.

      I have a few old boxes of Speer 180 gr. hollow points, and a few old boxes of Hornady 180 gr. XTPs. I only have one box of the Sierra Power Jackets.

      I may just load all of the Sierra bullets for the pistol, so I have enough to fill all three mags, then more than enough to fill all three mags at least once more. I have been saving the defense ammo I have had in the pistol for years, for the most part not shooting any of those, except for some I used on some coons one night a couple years ago. I have been running FMJ ammo through the gun for years, when I want to target practice. There have been many times over the years, I did not shoot at something because I did not want to burn up what little defense ammo I had.

      I plan on buying a 180 gr. and maybe a 200 gr. 10mm/40 caliber mold, and casting most of the bullets I shoot in the future. Then save the hollow point stuff for mostly hunting, or pest extermination.
      Last edited by RifleBowPistol; 11-27-2022, 09:25 AM.

      Comment


        #4
        So I decided to go with a 9.5 gr. charge, because, I would be able to use it in my pistol also. I loaded up 15 and went and shot some. The first shot gave me a velocity of 1486 fps. I am happy with that, after seeing what I was getting with the factory ammo. The primers look good, and the brass looks good.

        I went through my 10mm brass, and found I have more small primer pocket brass than I thought, it's all CCI brass. I am guessing I bought three or four boxes of the CCI Blazer ammo. I may make it a point to buy more of that ammo, if I find more. I have about 2000 pieces of 10mm brass, that have large pistol primer pockets, then somewhere between 100 and 200 of the small pistol primer pocket CCI brass.
        Last edited by RifleBowPistol; 12-10-2022, 11:16 PM.

        Comment


          #5
          Can you EVER post without writing a book? No smiley face. Serious question.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by trophy8 View Post
            Can you EVER post without writing a book? No smiley face. Serious question.
            My posts were not posted up for you, I post info for people searching for info on similar projects they are working on. Subjects, that I know there is not much info on the subject, because I have already searched for many hours and found either nothing or very vague info. I could be a **** and just post pictures and vague info, so the next person trying to do something similar, gets crap for info from my posts, like the few posts I found on the same subject.

            The more info on a subject, the more people will decided to start and finish similar projects, that creates more interest in that subject, more interest, means more companies will notice the interest and start making parts. That puts more choices for parts out there. It takes time, but it has to start somewhere. Other people have built 10mm ARs before me, but I only found very vague info on the parts used and what parts worked together, or problems guys had when trying to use various parts together. So if I post about the subject, I am going to try and contribute as much info to the subject as possible, for other people searching for info on that subject. So that is why I don't just post pretty pictures with 20 seconds of info.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by trophy8 View Post
              Can you EVER post without writing a book? No smiley face. Serious question.
              Originally posted by RifleBowPistol View Post
              My posts were not posted up for you, I post info for people searching for info on similar projects they are working on. Subjects, that I know there is not much info on the subject, because I have already searched for many hours and found either nothing or very vague info. I could be a **** and just post pictures and vague info, so the next person trying to do something similar, gets crap for info from my posts, like the few posts I found on the same subject.



              The more info on a subject, the more people will decided to start and finish similar projects, that creates more interest in that subject, more interest, means more companies will notice the interest and start making parts. That puts more choices for parts out there. It takes time, but it has to start somewhere. Other people have built 10mm ARs before me, but I only found very vague info on the parts used and what parts worked together, or problems guys had when trying to use various parts together. So if I post about the subject, I am going to try and contribute as much info to the subject as possible, for other people searching for info on that subject. So that is why I don't just post pretty pictures with 20 seconds of info.


              Cliff notes version:

              No, he can’t.


              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

              Comment


                #8
                I didn’t see the barrel length or what kinda pistol you’re shooting (didn’t read the whole encyclopedia), but a 180 at 1400 is pretty spicy. I like it.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Factory loaded 10mm definitely sucks and is just a touch warmer than 40cal. I need to get back to my 10mm project. What pistol are you shooting? Doesn’t look to be a Glock by primer strikes.

                  FYI I like details keep it up.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Good data. As you found out factory 10mm is practically no different than 40 S&W loads. If you want to bring out the true capability of 10mm you have to reload or hope a boutique manufacturer loads what you're looking for.

                    Mihec makes very nice 10mm HP molds. I got in on a few group buys on the cast boolits forum. They took over a year to come in but well worth the wait.

                    What 10mm carbine are you shooting?

                    Sent from my SM-A135U1 using Tapatalk

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by BLACKFINTURKEY View Post
                      Factory loaded 10mm definitely sucks and is just a touch warmer than 40cal. I need to get back to my 10mm project. What pistol are you shooting? Doesn’t look to be a Glock by primer strikes.

                      FYI I like details keep it up.
                      No Glock, it's a EEA Witness, CZ75 copy. I did not realize that some 10mm ammo was loaded so lightly, until I decided to shoot some over the chronograph. I have never liked loading small pistol calibers, 9mm, 40 S&W, 10mm 45 ACP, I would rather just buy factory ammo. But now seeing velocities of the ammo I have carried for years, I will be loading my 10mm ammo. That and as expensive and hard to find as 10mm defense ammo is, I don't want to buy some and find that it is light loaded like the Federal ammo.
                      Last edited by RifleBowPistol; 11-28-2022, 08:22 AM.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by TacticalCowboy View Post
                        I didn’t see the barrel length or what kinda pistol you’re shooting (didn’t read the whole encyclopedia), but a 180 at 1400 is pretty spicy. I like it.
                        The pistol is an EEA Witness. The carbine has a 16" barrel.

                        From what I have read on multiple handgun forums, guys claim they are getting around 1500 fps from 10mm pistols. I have been thinking that sounded like BS for years, but then have other guys say yes, they get those velocities. The last time I looked at a loading manual for handgun data for a 10mm, I thought 1300 fps was on the high end. But that's not what I have been reading on various forums.

                        Basically what I got, was typically 1200 fps to 1250 fps from the hotter factory loads. With what I considered good defense loads, producing right at 1000 fps, up to 1060 fps. That's lower than the numbers I have read for 40 S&W loads. The load I am going to use for both the pistol and the carbine, should get me around mid to upper 1200 fps from the pistol, then probably mid 1400 fps from the carbine.

                        Then I found out, that no, you can not load blowback 10mm carbine ammo hotter than 10mm pistol ammo. I looked at the chamber end of my pistol and turns out the feed ramp does not extend any distance into the chamber. That explains why I found 10mm handgun loads, loaded up to 36,000 psi, as where most of the 9mm handgun ammo was listed at I think 32,000 psi. I think I saw two loads in my Hornady manual for 38, 000 psi max pressure.

                        I spent a lot of time reading on this subject on various forums, and really did not find any info that said, this is the maximum pressure that you can use in a blowback carbine, and here are what you can expect for velocities.

                        Most of the info on 10mms I have found lately, has been guys claiming that a 10mm can be loaded to basically 41 Mag power levels. I knew that was not true, definitely not true, with any common autoloader handgun.

                        With the one powder I have, Longshot which I suspect should give the best numbers out of a carbine, with it's slower burn rates. I found that the manual was pretty much on the money, with 9.5 gr. being max charge, for the carbine. But I loaded some up to 11 gr. I found those cases got stretched out quite a bit. The primers looked like the pressures were a bit too hot, but not very hot. But after I ran those cases through the sizing die. I found those cases had been stretched out quite a bit larger all the way to the base of the case. They look like belted magnum cases, after I ran them through a sizing die. I learned very quickly over the weekend, that there are other things that happen besides primers flattening out, with a blowback gun.
                        I think I am going to look for a heavier buffer spring for the gun, and maybe add weight to the buffer. The buffer kit I am using, is designed for 9mms, not a 10mm, with it's higher pressures. The gun works very reliably with the parts I have in it, but I am pretty sure, it would work better with a heavier buffer spring and heavier buffer.
                        When I was shooting the lower powered factory loads, the recoil was very mild, but when I shot the hotter factory loads, the recoil went up noticeably, then with my hand loads, it definitely went up some more. Those low end factory loads, were probably loaded to typical 9mm pressures.

                        I did start looking at delayed blow back CMMG stuff and gas operated barrels. Then MikeD said, those guns use a 6.8 SPC bolt, that's easy to get. I am going to call CMMG and another company that makes gas charged barrels for 10mms, get some info from both.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          It appears the Quickload data I gave you was spot on. I always though the variance I got on pistols was due to the faster powders. Now I kind of wonder if it has more to do with the shorter barrels or lock time variances. Looks like you need to go pick up some AA7 to get another 100 fps and still be at 37K.

                          FYI, that 11gr load was at 52k and would have blown out on most any pistol.


                          What brass catcher are you running? You might also want to watch which way the gun throws brass to see if you need to make any changes.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by andre3k View Post
                            Good data. As you found out factory 10mm is practically no different than 40 S&W loads. If you want to bring out the true capability of 10mm you have to reload or hope a boutique manufacturer loads what you're looking for.

                            Mihec makes very nice 10mm HP molds. I got in on a few group buys on the cast boolits forum. They took over a year to come in but well worth the wait.

                            What 10mm carbine are you shooting?

                            Sent from my SM-A135U1 using Tapatalk
                            The gun, is one I pieced together, worked most of the bugs out of it, I think it still needs a heavier buffer spring and buffer.

                            I have not heard of Mihec, I will look for them. I have been buying molds from NOE. The only molds I have bought so far, they seem to be pretty good molds. I will look into Mihec.

                            I am going to put together a 9mm carbine next, I figure it with cast bullets should be very cheap to shoot. I could easily buy bulk ammo for it, and find jacketed bullets of various types, much easier. The basic plan is to get each carbine working very well, then work on getting set up to cast bullets for each caliber and load ammo with those cast bullets. So I can shoot both guns as much as I choose. I used to shoot a lot, weekly, but for years I have not been able to. I want to get back to shooting hundreds to maybe thousands of rounds at least monthly, if not weekly. I bought a five gallon bucket, that is half full of 9mm brass. I plan on loading a lot. But I have to find a good source of primers. The current primer situation ain't going to work. I think I have between 2000 to 3000 pieces of 10mm brass, that I have saved over the years, of shooting my 10mm pistols. Whatever I have, it should be plenty. Coming up with that many large or small pistol primers is going to be hard, and probably expensive.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by RifleBowPistol View Post

                              From what I have read on multiple handgun forums, guys claim they are getting around 1500 fps from 10mm pistols. I have been thinking that sounded like BS for years, but then have other guys say yes, they get those velocities. The last time I looked at a loading manual for handgun data for a 10mm, I thought 1300 fps was on the high end. But that's not what I have been reading on various forums.
                              Key word here is forums. I've read the same stuff and I wouldn't try it. I have the same pistol as you with the 6" long slide. I have a load that pushes the 180gr XTP to just shy of 1400 fps but it would be considered a +P load. I might could get to 1500 with 155's but no way with a 5" barrel. The big issue with running a semi auto pistol hot is the case support. Some pistols are better than others though.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X