Age of this deer?

[Brute Killer]

The only pics I have of him.
Snapped off of the computer screen with my phone.
Sorry for the quality.

[Brute Killer]

Also this one. Only pic I have.

[RMW]

Top buck 2.5-3.5
Bottom buck 4.5+ best I can tell with that 1 pic

[BolilloLoco]

4-5
Both of them

[jathomas437]

3.5

[Brute Killer]

I thought the first one was old and in decline. He has a long nose and you could hang your hat on his hip bone.

[lmartin5]

Top buck 2.5-3.5
Bottom buck 4.5+ best I can tell with that 1 pic

This

[RMW]

I thought the first one was old and in decline. He has a long nose and you could hang your hat on his hip bone.

Got more pics of Top buck? Not seeing a very old deer with those pics.

[Brute Killer]

No more pics of either.

[TXHunteronnie]

3.5 top
Can't see enough in the bottom picture to make a call.

[HoustonHunter]

Top buck 2.5-3.5
Bottom buck 4.5+ best I can tell with that 1 pic

I concur

[coffmanbr1]

I thought the first one was old and in decline. He has a long nose and you could hang your hat on his hip bone.

He does have a long nose, but all the other "signs" suggest hes young. If I was guessing I would go with you on him. I think he's older too. Hard to tell.

[gingib]

Top buck 2.5-3.5
Bottom buck 4.5+ best I can tell with that 1 pic

Hard to tell in velvet but this would be my guess

[SB09]

Top buck looks young. You've got to factor in all of the age indicators and make a decision. You can't use one attribute and ignore the others.

[Brute Killer]

Top buck looks young. You've got to factor in all of the age indicators and make a decision. You can't use one attribute and ignore the others.

I suppose he would also have trashy antlers or at least bases, too.
Probably is young.