age guess? on new guy

[bowhunter0]

Any guesses, first pic I've got of him and his neck looks about twice the size of the 6 point who i think is around 2.5 doesn't have the best rack but he looks like the most mature deer I've seen on my place. First pic is him, second pic is 2.5 year old 6 point. It's the only pic I've got of him and I'm just judging based on his neck.

[cwbow]

Maybe 4.5 I will say 3.5.

[Richard]

4.5

[bowhunter0]

pretty good for a public land deer huh? I guess the rut is starting up over here?

[gator man]

2.5

[Corner-tang]

2,5 max very young

[R Herline Jr]

2.5 to 3.5