What would you do?

[7sdad]

Shoot him and get his G2 fixed or let him walk and go after your #2?



Forum Buck below

[Walker]

I'd just hope he shows up in daylight.

[7sdad]

I'd just hope he shows up in daylight.

Both have started this week.

[jshouse]

being busted up has never kept me shooting a deer and i dont get them fixed. a whole beam missing might be a different story.

[Throwin Darts]

Shoot him if you like him but mount him like he was when he died. I don't get the "fixing" mounts deal.

[PondPopper]

Fixing that point is easy, or not..
Getting him the bed of the truck will be the part I’d be concentrating on.
Great buck. Good luck.

[Reaper87]

Mature buck. Kill him if you want to but mount him as he is or give him another year.

[Bucknaked]

I made the mistake of not killing the biggest axis buck I’ve ever seen this spring due to his fronts being broken! I look at his picture weekly and feel like I should punch myself in my own face () for not taking him! If you like him don’t let him pass ! I know that I won’t again!

[7sdad]

.

[PassnItOn]

tough call, I like junk so number 2 is appealing as well, number 1 definitely scores well. Probably the first one to mess up for me

[GarGuy]

tough call, I like junk so number 2 is appealing as well, number 1 definitely scores well. Probably the first one to mess up for me

Yep, whichever one shows first!

[deerdynasty]

I would shoot that buck before someone else does!!

[Hogmauler]

I fixed a buck when I blew part of his 2 off with a buck shot pellet. But for a small old break probably wouldn’t. If hes not larger than what you have give him a pass for another season unless you need the meat.

[Big pig]

I ‘d hunt for oldest deer. Seriously.
If they are same age
good for you !

never fixing a point but that’s me

BP

[7sdad]

I ended up getting a shot at this one and I'm happy, the other buck has gone awal the past few weeks. Hopefully he hasn't got shot by a neighbors.