Let him walk or cull him out?

[KevinG]

What do you think his age and score are?

[Silent Assassin]

Can't help you out, I'm no deer expert in this case. Bump for ya!

[jathomas437]

3, maybe 3.5 years old... will be a giant bruiser in a couple more years.

[PondPopper]

4.5 cull short pins

[Mac...]

His weak side will always remain weak due to an injury, but he is passing on some awesome traits and still has some growing to do.

If he's low fence, I'd let him keep breeding!
He'll be bigger in a couple of years and still passing seed in the mean time

High fence..... If'y....

[jathomas437]

4.5 cull short pins

tines?

[cjkozik]

4.5 let him walk

[doghouse]

Walk this year with the drought we are in.

[mTn hunting]

10 good knife handles are all i see!

[Redraider]

depends what your management practices are. If you don't have a lot of bucks than let him breed.

[KevinG]

This is low fence..

I am not sure if it was injury or just gene's...... Here is a picture of his younger brother... He has much better tine length on the strong side but same weak side...

[Mac...]

Hmmmmm....... I retract.... Cull him!

[tbgascorer]

Post mature older buck on the downhill slide, get him.

[sharkhunter]

That deer is at least 4.5+++... Cull him fo sho...

[jathomas437]

That deer is at least 4.5+++... Cull him fo sho...

I stand corrected. He does have a good belly on him.