Swhacker or Grim reaper?

[TexShadow74]

I will say the reaper. I wanted to see what one could do before the coming season so I used it on a hog. You can see the aftermath on my thread Boar vs Grim Reaper.

[Rick_R22]

100 grain will do the job

Sent from my HTC EVO 4G

[TX_Phil]

Here's an exit wound picture from a buck I shot this past season. The broadhead was a grim reaper whitetail special. Shot was at 18yrds from an elevated stand.

As you can see this shot was not a good one, it was a liver shot. I'm clearly not bragging on my shot placement but rather using this to make a point. With a perfect shot any broadhead will do the job but what I want is a broadhead that helps when I make a mistake. Like this shot. Everything looked perfect until I touched the release and he step and turned a little. The result was a liver shot with a massive amount of blood. He ran about 20yrd from the shot and dropped in his tracks. Watched him expire.

[systemnt]

I'm a believer of the schwacker. Thats what i use..no complaints at all.
Split a does heart in two last year.. ran about 30 years painting the woods.. didn't have enough blood left in her to collect for the tracking dog training..

Seen the reapers carnage too... they do the job as well.

[JerryR]

If your shooting 55 lbs of draw weight. How much energy are you producing?

Speed?
Arrow Weight?

[ProV1]

If your shooting 55 lbs of draw weight. How much energy are you producing?

Speed?
Arrow Weight?

Here comes Jerry and his slide rule. Being an engineer I love this part.

[Sleepy]

EPEK broadheads

[SabineRR]

If your shooting 55 lbs of draw weight. How much energy are you producing?

Speed?
Arrow Weight?

Just around 290 fps probably... Never done a speed test and not sure how much the 250 mutiny's weigh either..

[JerryR]

Just around 290 fps probably... Never done a speed test and not sure how much the 250 mutiny's weigh either..

What are you spec?
Bow?
Draw Length?
Arrow Length & tip weight?

[Arrow Slinger88]

Reaper

[SabineRR]

What are you spec?
Bow?
Draw Length?
Arrow Length & tip weight?

Bow: 2012 pse stinger 3g hp IBO: 314 fps
Draw Length: 27
Arrow length: 27.75
Field tip weight?: 125 grains

[BamaXbow]

Swhacker... Not even one vote! They can't be that bad... The shoot thru ply wood!

Grim Reaper... watch em drop.
Swhacker... Open so fast you can hear them Swack.

IMO... It doesn't matter what blade you shoot, what bow you have... It's you. You put a good shot on an animal your gonna hear the impact and watch em drop.

[txstrapassassin]

just bought a package if sheackers....can't wait to usem

[techbowhunter7]

grim reaper

[JerryR]

Bow: 2012 pse stinger 3g hp IBO: 314 fps
Draw Length: 27
Arrow length: 27.75
Field tip weight?: 125 grains

Your speed is going to be around 245-255 fps with your setup. Arrow weight with tip included is around 402 grains +or -. That would put your KE at 55.80 ft lbs and is boarder line for using a grim reaper broadhead. Just stay with the 1 3/8 cut it requires less energy to open.