They are all culls, kill em all! Kill kill kill
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Culling doesn’t work
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Smart View PostI see we have a Cotulla cowboy hung up on semantics in our midst....
One can 100% cull/kill less desirable deer out of the herd to remove mouths to allow their better traited deer better nutrition resources. All without any regards concerning improving overall genetics and with full regard for trying to grow the deer alive in front of you bigger. This is not that hard. Age and nutrition availability are things you can control with culling....genetics are not..
Is culling, killing?.....well of course it is. Selection and rejection for a purpose ...aka culling. If one is a Cotulla Cowboy or a DillyBar and they can't get past this, call it what you or your armchair biologist manual says....just don't get your panties in a wad when folks use the word in its true definition.
Culling vs. Population Control are two completely different subjects. You can cull a couple of deer on a high fence ranch you don't like ( has nothing to do with population)... or you can go kill 20 does to help with population control ( has nothing to do with culling) .
If you're LF, unless you have thousands upon thousands of acres you're killing. I can back it up with study after study.... what are you backing it up with? Beans in chili?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mexico View PostBean cooker you take life too seriously... step away from that table a bit
Culling vs. Population Control are two completely different subjects. You can cull a couple of deer on a high fence ranch you don't like ( has nothing to do with population)... or you can go kill 20 does to help with population control ( has nothing to do with culling) .
If you're LF, unless you have thousands upon thousands of acres you're killing. I can back it up with study after study.... what are you backing it up with? Beans in chili?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mexico View PostBean cooker you take life too seriously... step away from that table a bit
Culling vs. Population Control are two completely different subjects. You can cull a couple of deer on a high fence ranch you don't like ( has nothing to do with population)... or you can go kill 20 does to help with population control ( has nothing to do with culling) .
If you're LF, unless you have thousands upon thousands of acres you're killing. I can back it up with study after study.... what are you backing it up with? Beans in chili?
Comment
-
Originally posted by bphillips View PostPopulation control will also include bucks. If your taking 10 bucks with those 20 does and pay no mind to the age or quality of the buck it killing. If you do pay attention to the age and quality to determine which bucks to take you’re back to culling. It’s the same goal with a different name. I’d bet you do it LF in Mexico just like we do. Killing, culling, management they’re all just deer getting shot because they aren’t worth keeping on the feed bill
Comment
-
Originally posted by bphillips View PostPopulation control will also include bucks. If your taking 10 bucks with those 20 does and pay no mind to the age or quality of the buck it killing. If you do pay attention to the age and quality to determine which bucks to take you’re back to culling. It’s the same goal with a different name. I’d bet you do it LF in Mexico just like we do. Killing, culling, management they’re all just deer getting shot because they aren’t worth keeping on the feed bill
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mexico View PostBean cooker you take life too seriously... step away from that table a bit
Originally posted by Mexico View PostIf you want to reduce mouths go for it, but that's killing not culling. Call it what it is.
You are confusing me laughing and making light of your absoluteness because your pocket manual says something.... push away from the TTHA and QDMA circle jerk..
Is this where I add a few of these..
Again....WE ARE NOT THINKING WE ARE IMPROVING OVERALL GENETICS...WE ARE JUST TRYING TO IMPROVE THE INDIVIDUAL DEER WE HAVE THAT SHOW BETTER TRAITS by selecting and rejecting......I have said that at least 4 times now. Good grief!
Comment
-
Originally posted by Smart View PostYou are confusing me laughing and making light of your absoluteness because your pocket manual says something.... push away from the TTHA and QDMA circle jerk..
Is this where I add a few of these..
Again....WE ARE NOT THINKING WE ARE IMPROVING OVERALL GENETICS...WE ARE JUST TRYING TO IMPROVE THE INDIVIDUAL DEER WE HAVE THAT SHOW BETTER TRAITS by selecting and rejecting......I have said that at least 4 times now. Good grief!
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Comment
-
Originally posted by Mexico View PostI like me some QDMA, maybe you should check them out. Might help reduce some of your mistakes Could care less about TTHA. Now I have some beans to stir... good day gents!
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Couldn't*..
You also misspelled...."Smart...I don't know why I keep mentioning improving genetics when you have said you aren't doing that 4 times......"Last edited by Smart; 10-20-2019, 10:08 AM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by bphillips View Postpopulation control will also include bucks. If your taking 10 bucks with those 20 does and pay no mind to the age or quality of the buck it killing. If you do pay attention to the age and quality to determine which bucks to take you’re back to culling. It’s the same goal with a different name. I’d bet you do it lf in mexico just like we do. Killing, culling, management they’re all just deer getting shot because they aren’t worth keeping on the feed bill
Thank you Bobby!!!!! ...
Comment
-
At what point does management take the excitement out of a hunt? I know a few guys who have managed deer herds until they lost the excitement and never hunted again. For what it’s worth you can grow big deer on a big low fence place, just feed em and let em get old. Letting em get old is much harder than I ever imagined LoL
Comment
Comment