Which QB has most to win or lose

[bps3040]

Heard this subject on talk radio today..... Thought it was good question

Which QB has most to win or lose winning /losing?

I say Romo. He wins, he gets everybody off his back about choking.... He loses, there will twice as much talk.

Manning also, though not to that extent. He wins, one of best QB's in history. Loses.... Great, but rarely won the big games

What y'all think?

[3DW5]

You would be correct, Romo needs to win so people will get off his back....

[blntrey3]

Both are fair choices^^^^^^

I am a Manning fan and it is aggravating that people compare a team Award (Trophy to a Individual)-----He has 5 MVP's most in History plus almost every other Individual Record.

I know it's about titles.....so I think he has most to lose or gain

[Smart]

Firstly, with the way Romo has handled his game this year, if he doesn't turn the ball over several times and the defense gets driven, only a ballwatcher would blame it on him choking..

In the grand scheme of it all, Rodgers and his teams have choked several times in the playoffs as well since his 2010 Super Bowl. If he doesn't get the win, he'll catch hell as well. Hell earlier in the year before his "relax" comment, folks were calling for his head....same with Brady.

My vote is they both have a lot to gain and a lot to lose from the ballwatchers but the Cowboys' team has more to gain due to their poor postseason participation since the Super Bowls.

[sethcros]

I agree, but why would there be twice as much talk? I guess the haters will hate unless he wins a super bowl every year, but if they just lose to the Packers in Green Bay?

[DRT]

Don't you think we should wait until after the game at Lambo to discuss this? I think the Packers are beatable but I still think the game needs to be played before we put Tony in the Superbowl.

[Smart]

Never mind....you said Super Bowl....I thought you were talking about this playoff game. I agree with DRT.....this thread is way too premature and the Seahwaks will have a lot to say about either getting in beforehand....

[sethcros]

Yeah, there's a whole lot of jinxness being brought up with a thread like this...

[bps3040]

Took out Super bowl part

[lovemylegacy]

Bunch of "choker" qbs in the playoffs, except for Joe Flacco. Romo probably stands to gain the most...but you know how the media is.

[Burntorange Bowhunter]

Every QB in the playoffs "chokes" except for one the way the average person uses that term.

[oktx]

Smart, would you please tell us what a ball watcher is?

[sethcros]

Smart, would you please tell us what a ball watcher is?

Haters

[Smart]

Smart, would you please tell us what a ball watcher is?

A ballwatcher is somebody like my wife. They love football and know a little bit about the game but they do nothing but watch the ball during the game. They don't watch the other facets like the Oline, Dline , receivers blocking, receivers running the wrong routes, defense not stopping the other team etc etc etc.

The easiest way to spot a ballwatcher is that they blame everything on the QB....everything....never paying attention to what really lost or won the game or who actually made the mistakes. They also think the QB wins every game...

[oktx]

A ballwatcher is somebody like my wife. They love football and know a little bit about the game but they do nothing but watch the ball during the game. They don't watch the other facets like the Oline, Dline , receivers blocking, receivers running the wrong routes, defense not stopping the other team etc etc etc.

The easiest way to spot a ballwatcher is that they blame everything on the QB....everything....never paying attention to what really lost or won the game or who actually made the mistakes. They also think the QB wins every game...

Ok, that's what I thought it was. I was worried I was one for a sec.