Black Rack vs small sheds?

[Ender]

i did a search and didn't find anything so some of you more experience hunters please pass on some knowledge. I have a small 8pt set of sheds that i used to use and got something to come out once with them(when i say small i mean small about 12' from base to the end of the main beam). Last summer i bought a set of black rack antlers at a garage sale and i've used them a bit this year and i wondered which yall thought were better. any advice would be appreciated this is only my second year bowhunting and i admit i'm very inexperienced

[trey.c]

Nothing works better than the real deal

[Low Fence]

If they are going to respond to rattling, you can bang two pots together and they will come running. If they are not responding, the real thing won't effect them. I've used horns and several rattling bags. Some sounded good to my ears some like crap... All worked

[Ender]

Ttt

[Saddle Tramp]

I use a small set of real ants.
Big rack rattles seem to be bigger than the deer in the areas I hunt so they don't come in to fight a big boys.
Just my thoughts has been working though.