Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Concrete quality

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #61
    At one time, I worked for a engineering testing lab and my primary job was controlling/inspecting concrete. We developed mix designs, tested materials, tested concrete, oversaw mixing at the plant, and made/tested samples from the field. I've personally controlled pours for everything from 20 story buildings to residential flatwork. As others have stated or implied, there are a lot of ways to make concrete strong and durable and just as many ways to mess it up.

    I don't know what your project involves but the best advice I can offer on the limited space of a forum like this is to use the best ready-mix plant you can find. My guess is that your project is not commercial so the expense of hiring an engineering firm to oversee the project is out of the question. Therefore, you are at the mercy of the mix plant and its employees. (Truck drivers, alone, can mess up a load my adding too much water to make driving easier, or by not thoroughly mixing the load so they can save time and make more loads. They can also fail to empty the drum of rinse water before adding a new load - increasing the water to cement ratio.)

    I'm sure most companies try to do things right and I'm not saying they don't. I'm just trying to point out that it is sometimes a matter of "let the buyer beware". Choose your mix plant and contractors wisely.

    Comment


      #62
      Originally posted by hammackc View Post
      Some Hi Early, in cool weather, 6 sack design ( 360 mix, TXDOT ), rest of the time, if we need it rapidly, yes Hi Early!
      We poured 50 yards wednesday, 39 today, and have 25 for tomorrow in University Park, Hi Early, it was a street repair.

      Comment


        #63
        High early is not needed for 5500psi @ 28 days.

        Comment


          #64
          Originally posted by ZZ Pops View Post
          At one time, I worked for a engineering testing lab and my primary job was controlling/inspecting concrete. We developed mix designs, tested materials, tested concrete, oversaw mixing at the plant, and made/tested samples from the field. I've personally controlled pours for everything from 20 story buildings to residential flatwork. As others have stated or implied, there are a lot of ways to make concrete strong and durable and just as many ways to mess it up.

          I don't know what your project involves but the best advice I can offer on the limited space of a forum like this is to use the best ready-mix plant you can find. My guess is that your project is not commercial so the expense of hiring an engineering firm to oversee the project is out of the question. Therefore, you are at the mercy of the mix plant and its employees. (Truck drivers, alone, can mess up a load my adding too much water to make driving easier, or by not thoroughly mixing the load so they can save time and make more loads. They can also fail to empty the drum of rinse water before adding a new load - increasing the water to cement ratio.)

          I'm sure most companies try to do things right and I'm not saying they don't. I'm just trying to point out that it is sometimes a matter of "let the buyer beware". Choose your mix plant and contractors wisely.
          I have been to batch plants and asked what there moistures are, and just got a blank look. Same thing when I ask about there unit weights. A truck driver can really mess up your batch by over overmixing also. Also over vibrating is not good. If you see any segregation in you concrete when they are pouring dont be scared to stop the pour and reject that load.

          Comment


            #65
            Originally posted by Clint View Post
            High early is not needed for 5500psi @ 28 days.
            Who said anything about 28 days, we drove 80K pound concrete trucks on it 36 hours after it was poured.

            Comment


              #66
              FYI….If any of you know anyone with any Precast experience, we're looking to hire. Precast sanitary manholes, storm sewer structures, etc. Hiring Production Manager just north of Houston. PM me for details.

              Comment


                #67
                Originally posted by curtintex View Post
                FYI….If any of you know anyone with any Precast experience, we're looking to hire. Precast sanitary manholes, storm sewer structures, etc. Hiring Production Manager just north of Houston. PM me for details.
                Do yall do txdot jobs?

                Comment


                  #68
                  Originally posted by Hoyt Man View Post
                  Do yall do txdot jobs?
                  No sir. Not yet. Just started operations last June. Business is BOOMING, but not ready to delve into TxDot yet.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X