need help: legal? possible age?

[txrzr]

First time this guy has ever came to visit. A couple of us looked at him and dont think he is broke off but its hard to tell. Can anyone share some opinions on him being legal.

[Johnny quest]

I think it's an 3and 1/2 year old. I also think it's legal. Good luck on second and harder look it may require more observation. It could be broken and a very nice deer next year!

[txrzr]

Hard to tell with him being all puffed up

[twobittxn]

Not legal. Not a 13" spread. Not a spike on the right side. Assuming its an AR county.

[randal]

I say legal

[Hamshire]

All depends on if that little guy on the right beam is an inch long. I want him to be legal for ya. I also say 3.5 is a good estimate.

[txrzr]

Ya its hard to say in pictures until you lay eyes on him! I wouldnt mind some meat in the freezer for sure!

[dustoffer]

I'm in a AR county and I'd shoot it--no way that "point" is an inch long.

[Antlers86]

I say he is broke! Hard decision. If you look at his left eye guard it is broken. Just have to see in person. Good luck.

[panhandlehunter]

Yeah he broke off his main beam just past his G1. Let him walk.

[tfire25]

Anybody else thinking Eliot off of open season? I would let him walk though.