Input on the age of this Erath County buck?

[BH15]

I have nice eight point with a ten point. I have picture from last year of this same ten point. He appears to be a little wider this year. I think they are both young though. Thoughts??

[solocam_aggie]

Buck in the last pic is not that young. 4.5 at the minimum. The other buck in top pic is young. 2.5 maybe

[bowaddict40]

Would agree with the 4.5

[BH15]

Thanks for the input thus far. This is only 75 acres and it is low fenced so I am thinking I will let my son shoot the 10 if we see him.

[jetlag887]

I agree with 4.5

[TXSHUNTERS]

hard to say in the first pic....but the last pic he looks 4.5 or older.

[BULL21]

I saw 4.5 too

[EastTexasMan]

the 10 to me is def 4.5 or older

[Russ]

Both are older deer....minimum 4 on the 10 and I would say the same on the 8 too. No way that long faced fellow is only 2 with that fast belly!

[TXUSMC]

Makes me excited about my firts hunt in Erath Co this year.

[Txpepper]

3.5 on the 8 and 3.5 on the 10.

[MassMan]

Hard to tell on the 8 but I think the 10 is at least a 5 year old.

[Axis FMJ]

Second pic I say 5.

[BH15]

Thanks everybody. I did some more research on againg and have to agree with the 4.5 to 5 years on the 10 point. Hope he sticks around.

[cactus kid]

I can't make him out to be older than 3.5. Very distinguished neck/shoulder area, hams seem much deeper than chest cavity, kind of a race horse look. Maybe I'm missing something,

Why do you guys think 4.5 or 5.5?