Originally posted by Smart
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
A Game Of Thrones
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Skinny View PostMan we can't hardly watch nothing with adult content around here during the summer. Kids are here all day...up all night...etc. I guess when school starts and they get to bed at a decent hour I can see about starting it. Lol
Skinny
Comment
-
Originally posted by catslayer View PostThat family tree is a guess... its 50/50 who johns dad is
Lyanna Stark was almost 100% his mother.
But his father was either Robert Baratheon, concieved on Bear island. They were in love. And robert was in love with her till the day she died... (which is why Circe HATED him after they got married)
Or Rhagar Targaryn, concieved after he kidnapped and was assumed ravaged her. (Kidnap started Roberts rebellion basically)
We dont KNOW when Ned and Cranig fought up to the tower against sir walter dane in Dorn( we saw fight last season) ned went up... came back with kid... thats all we know thus far
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
I don't think Lyanna was "kidnapped", I think she fell in love with Rhaegar and went with him willingly. It was known that Lyanna didn't even like the idea of marrying Robert B., she thought he was a drunk and a womanizer. Besides, Robert and Lyanna were not married yet, no chance of RB + LS = JS. I think it's pretty clear, RT + LS = JS. Also, why would the Targ's post Arthur Dane, their best swordsman, as her personal guard during a time of war, if there was not something very important to protect. He was protecting Rhaegars unborn child and Lyanna.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Birddog66 View PostPersonally, it's pretty clear to me who JS parents are. I hear what your saying, but it sounds like your playing a lot of "what if's".
I don't think Lyanna was "kidnapped", I think she fell in love with Rhaegar and went with him willingly. It was known that Lyanna didn't even like the idea of marrying Robert B., she thought he was a drunk and a womanizer. Besides, Robert and Lyanna were not married yet, no chance of RB + LS = JS. I think it's pretty clear, RT + LS = JS. Also, why would the Targ's post Arthur Dane, their best swordsman, as her personal guard during a time of war, if there was not something very important to protect. He was protecting Rhaegars unborn child and Lyanna.
I agree with that.... although these folks have been throwing us curveballs all season[emoji41]
Comment
-
Originally posted by Birddog66 View PostPersonally, it's pretty clear to me who JS parents are. I hear what your saying, but it sounds like your playing a lot of "what if's".
I don't think Lyanna was "kidnapped", I think she fell in love with Rhaegar and went with him willingly. It was known that Lyanna didn't even like the idea of marrying Robert B., she thought he was a drunk and a womanizer. Besides, Robert and Lyanna were not married yet, no chance of RB + LS = JS. I think it's pretty clear, RT + LS = JS. Also, why would the Targ's post Arthur Dane, their best swordsman, as her personal guard during a time of war, if there was not something very important to protect. He was protecting Rhaegars unborn child and Lyanna.
Now ill pull a book comment that may or may not matter... in the book i cant remember lyanna having bad feelings for Robert, but i could be wrong. If you can ref where it does id love to go back and look...
The story has very much set us up to wonder the 50/50 of Johns Dad
Im gona pm you somthing so i dont push ppls buttons with somthing...
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
Comment
Comment