I'm taking debate this semester at Tarleton and for it we have to give 2 speeches,one for something and the other against it. We could pick our own topics so I picked Antler Restrictions in Texas. What are some good reasons to have it??? I need at least 3.
-
-
It disallows a hunters god given right to harvest an animal for the purpose of feeding his family. Placing emphasis on the beauty (size) of ones antlers instead of the beauty of the hunt and nourishment the meat will provide you.
-
C'mon texmax, it is 2012. NOBODY hunts for the primary purpose of feeding their family. If that were the case, there are plenty of does to shoot. Get real man.
Antler restrictions are beneficial to the overall age structure of a given population by protecting a large percentage of the youngest age class of deer, and allowing them to mature to breeding age.Comment
-
The purpose of this thread was to present angles, for the benefit of the op's speech. That was one of them. If that is your stance I'm sure it would make an excellent 'for' argument.Originally posted by bowhuntntxn View Post
If your seeking a debate, you'll have to look elsewhere
.
Comment
-
The op is looking for reasons for and not against!Originally posted by TexMax View PostThe purpose of this thread was to present angles, for the benefit of the op's speech. That was one of them. If that is your stance I'm sure it would make an excellent 'for' argument.
If your seeking a debate, you'll have to look elsewhere.Comment
-
It prevents hunters from taking young deer (and a few narrow old ones). This allows deer to mature, thus allowing them to reach their full (sometimes) potential.Comment
-
Your reading it more literally than I was. I presumed that since he was giving speeches that will contradict each other he would need both sides.Originally posted by captainsling View Post
If I'm wrong, my apologies
Comment
-
Yes I need both side but I'm pretty sure I can wing being against it, I've just been having problems finding reason for why to be for itComment
-
They must be trying to groom some young politicians. One day you're for it, the next day you're against it. JKComment
-
There are no such thing as cull bucks if you have AR. That's a plus ain't it?Comment
-
Thanks for all the help!! I'm pretty sure I will be able to figure out how to argue for it!Comment
-
It allows several things in a specific area or county
1: Deer to age and mature
2: Better antlers for future hunters
3: Better management of the deer herd.
(Before the brown and down mentality is strong, lots of yound and immature deers are killed, thus hurting your deer herd 2-3 years down the road.)Comment
Comment