Which one?

[akey]

Which one of these bucks would you rather take? I hunt on land that is low fenced with other hunters that don't share my mindset of management. I will be gun hunting this year as I just got in to bowhunting. The first buck has alot of character and I really like his squirrely brow tines. The second buck seems to be bigger but narrower. I posted them both up in the Game Management forum and appreciate all the feed back I received.

#1






#2

[DFWPI]

Any of them?

[WCI]

Either one that presented a good shot opportunity.. Both are trophies in the own right.

[akey]

I hear you. This is my first year with really nice deer (to me) showing up so just looking for input.

[Cuz]

Either would do BUT IF they both walked out together on my first hunt I'd choose buck #1.

[HeyMikey]

You can't make a bad decision, whichever one you get a shot at. Good luck!

[Moose83]

I think I'd Have to take either one! I do like #1 better! Either one is a great Trophy!!!!

[LosCuernosRanch]

Wow tough call, both are great deer. I would take either.

[Swampa]

Shoot both of em. Theyre 8's.

[ShaBow]

Tough call but I'd have to say #1 no wait #2 no wait!In my case it would be the first one that gave me a good bow shot so the decision would be easier that way!I dont have an answer both really nice!

[Txbhunter1]

I would take the second one as he looks to be older than the first. Either way you go, they are both nice deer.

[Storm]

Take your pick.

[dcw]

Either would do BUT IF they both walked out together on my first hunt I'd choose buck #1.

^^^^^^This

[Exit110]

Either would do BUT IF they both walked out together on my first hunt I'd choose buck #1.

This

[Cooper]

Either one is a nice Buck; but I like the first Buck.