Did I Screw Up?

[BOWERIK]

First one looked 4.5; good deer. second one was built lik a 5.5 year old line backer of a deer; solid shoulders and swayed back. I know its tough when you only have one buck tag.

[Charles]

Don't second guess yourself by not shooting #1. He's a great deer that will be a spectacular deer next year. Deer #2 needs to go

[Tejas Wildlife]

Gotta agree with Atfulldraw & JMG. Hope the first deer survives the season because he will be a great deer next year and that fighting sonofagun would be taking a dirt nap!

Great photos.

[AMK]

Wow that cull has a monster neck!!

And the first one does look young but low fence and hill country.. depending on your neighbors.. i would have shot him!

x2

[chrisgunguy]

x3

[EASY]

Low fence. No question on either one. I would have let an arrow fly

[silentstare]

man that cull has a neck like a linebacker

[lakefork]

You can see in the secod pic of the first buck he is about to jump the fence. I would have smoked him before your neighbor gets him. lol

[Boar Stalker]

Both are great deer.

[tookeymonster]

It will be nice to see what the big racked buck looks like next year. But you should have stuck an arrow in that cull for sure! Don't you have 2 buck tags?

[Boomerang]

The neck is ready for the rut...WOW! First buck is very nice.

[Flint knapper]

yep you did!

[gatt40]

Yep. You screwed up again. I would have at least tried a shot on either one.

[Low Fence]

4.5 on first on - nice deer!

2nd one needs to be tested for roids! Looks like he came out of the locker room with A-Rod

[VorTexan]

1st one is a young 4.5 at best and the second is a lot of meat on the table.