Need your opinion

[BuckySWT]

Got two potentials for trophies (for me) this year. Got some other management deer that I know what do to with.

What are your thoughts on these two (ages and possible scores).

Buck A:
I'm calling 6 1/2 (since we've seen him the last 2 yrs, and he was mature the first year we saw him), and upper 140's.



Buck B:
5 1/2, upper 130's, lower 140's. got some character building on both g2's...possible double kickers next year (IF he sticks around...120 acres...solid brush).



Buck B has been around since early Aug. Buck A...this is year 3 we've seen him.


Came face to face with Buck A last night, no shot possible at 8 feet I'm leaning hard towards Buck A at this point.

[BuckySWT]

Buck A...evenings only pretty much.
Buck B...corn hog...you name the time...he's under the feeder pretty much.

[bscooten1974]

buck a def. maybe as old as a7 yr old(thats the one i'd want), buck b ain't no slouch 5 or 6 yr old. def shooters

[BURTONboy]

That's a tough call. They are both really good looking deer with some age on them. Buck A definitely looks to be an old boy. I think I would take which ever one shows up and get's you to shaking. Either one would look fine on a wall.

[slayer]

Buck A, give buck B time to get more mass and character. I personally would shoot either one.

[BuckySWT]

yeah...either one of these go down...shoulder mount for sure. Doesn't happen very often with me (once so far), but one of these will for sure deserve that honor. I usually do a european on rustic barnwood.

[Richard]

I would shoot the first one that gives you the perfect shot.

[gravesc987]

Buck A for sure, thats the old deer that i dream of shooting

[coachroc]

Either one

[leasecommander]

On 120 acres, shoot either one, both great deer for that kind of acreage, my preference is no. 2, but that is just me.

[Shake N' Bake]

A

[Cajun Blake]

dem corn bandits gotta go

buck A