Same buck?

[Montec man]

Sat down yesterday comparing last years pics to this years, and was able to match up quite a few of them. Still undecided on this one. Let me know if you think it's the same buck.

[happy bowhunter]

Beams turn up the same,G3 on left side is inside the G2,weak brows
Highly possible that it's the same buck

[BOWFISHER08]

looks like the same buck the way his tines match up
looks like he is just a little taller this year

[The Real McCoy]

if it is he came a long way

[DPerez905]

Its a good possibility

[gamegetter]

looks to be same deer

[bear]

just might be

[MassRut2]

I vote no the body is to big. If it is he has come a long way good management program.

[Old Blue]

He looks alot the same but larger could be

[Felix40]

They match up pretty close. I didnt think he was unreasonably bigger either. Only looks to be 18-20 inches bigger to me.

[JonBoy]

They look close but unless you had something concrete to go on (physical discriminators other than horns, i.e. a visible injury, etc) it would just be speculation at this point...

[bowmansdad]

Same buck.

[Montec man]

They look close but unless you had something concrete to go on (physical discriminators other than horns, i.e. a visible injury, etc) it would just be speculation at this point...

I don't have much else to go on besides configuration of the antlers. truth be told the main reason I want to say that it's not the same buck is the body size. He doesn't look any bigger to me (body-wise) than the pic from last year and if it is the same buck he should have made a bigger jump in body size. No more than 3.5 years old. Our 4.5 and older bucks are much, much larger and dwarf this buck. This youngster shows some promise and I'm sure the other lease members will agree that he needs a little TLC and a couple more years.

[SolocamShooter]

looks like the same buck...